Should West Michigan communities reform zoning laws to allow more housing density?
West Michigan needs an estimated 40,000–60,000 additional housing units by 2030 to meet population and household growth. The shortage is driving up rents and home prices across every income bracket, pushing workers out of the region and straining employer recruitment.
Yes — zoning reform is necessary to solve the housing shortage
No — communities should control their own character; density without infrastructure investment creates new problems
What people are saying for and against
My rent went from $1,100 to $1,650 between 2021 and 2024. My salary went up $800 over the same period.
I'm a teacher in the Kentwood district. My rent went from $1,100 to $1,650 between 2021 and 2024. My salary went up $800 over the same period. I spent 19 months on the MSHDA rental assistance waitlist. The reason this is happening is that we haven't built enough housing — and the reason we haven't built enough is that every township and city has discretionary zoning that makes multi-family housing nearly impossible to permit. Zoning reform is not optional.
Kent County needs roughly 30,000 additional units by 2030 according to the West Michigan Regional Planning Commission's own report.
Kent County needs roughly 30,000 additional units by 2030 according to the West Michigan Regional Planning Commission's own report. We are currently permitted to build about 3,000 per year. The arithmetic is simple. You cannot get to 30,000 units in a market where 80% of residential land is zoned single-family-only. The zoning code is the binding constraint. Everything else is secondary.
Missing middle housing — duplexes, triplexes, small apartment buildings
Missing middle housing — duplexes, triplexes, small apartment buildings — existed in every city in America before 1950 zoning codes made them illegal. We are not asking for something radical. We are asking to allow what every American city built for the first 150 years of urban development. The idea that allowing a fourplex next to a single-family home destroys neighborhood character is not supported by evidence from cities that have actually done this.
I've lived in my neighborhood for 22 years. We have one-lane roads, a stormwater system designed…
I've lived in my neighborhood for 22 years. We have one-lane roads, a stormwater system designed for current density, and schools that are already at capacity. "Zoning reform" that allows four-plexes by right means adding 400 units to a neighborhood whose infrastructure was designed for 100. I'm not opposed to housing — I'm opposed to growth that the township mandates without funding the infrastructure to support it.
The Grand Rapids ADU ordinance passed in 2022 was supposed to unleash new housing supply.
The Grand Rapids ADU ordinance passed in 2022 was supposed to unleash new housing supply. Two years later, permit applications for ADUs are running at about 40% of projections, largely because construction costs make the math not work without significant subsidies. Zoning reform is necessary but not sufficient. If we reform zoning without addressing construction financing and labor costs, we get rezoned land that still doesn't pencil out for developers.