Who should win Michigan's 2026 U.S. Senate race?
Mike Rogers (R), the unopposed GOP nominee, faces Abdul El-Sayed (D) in the race to fill Michigan's open U.S. Senate seat. Rogers is running on his national-security record from 14 years on the House Intelligence Committee; El-Sayed is running on his record as Oakland County Health Director and progressive foreign-policy positions.
Yes — support
No — oppose
Source Library Source Documents (4)
What people are saying for and against
El-Sayed's record as Oakland County Health Director
El-Sayed's record as Oakland County Health Director — building a public health infrastructure from scratch, expanding clinics, instituting data-driven outbreak response — is a concrete government management credential that Rogers, a career legislator, cannot match.
El-Sayed's two prior Democratic primary defeats — governor in 2018, U.S. House in 2020
El-Sayed's two prior Democratic primary defeats — governor in 2018, U.S. House in 2020 — show a consistent pattern: energizes the progressive base, loses general-election credibility. In a competitive state like Michigan, that record is a structural liability.
El-Sayed's primary victory shows he can build a winning coalition among Michigan Democrats.
El-Sayed's primary victory shows he can build a winning coalition among Michigan Democrats. If the 2024 "uncommitted" movement's 100,000-plus protest votes translate into general-election turnout — particularly with high Black voter turnout in Detroit and Flint — the race is closer than conventional wisdom suggests.
Michigan's largest metro areas have majority-minority populations, and the state has never sent a Black or Arab-American senator to Washington.
Michigan's largest metro areas have majority-minority populations, and the state has never sent a Black or Arab-American senator to Washington. Representation-based arguments favor El-Sayed symbolically, but Michigan's suburban swing voters have not historically rewarded identity-first candidacies.
Rogers' 14 years on the House Intelligence Committee — including his chairmanship
Rogers' 14 years on the House Intelligence Committee — including his chairmanship — gave him real working relationships with NATO allies, direct access to classified threat assessments, and credibility on national security that no other 2026 Michigan Senate candidate can match.
After 9/11, El-Sayed made statements — reported in multiple news outlets during his 2018…
After 9/11, El-Sayed made statements — reported in multiple news outlets during his 2018 gubernatorial run — that critics characterized as suggesting U.S. foreign policy invited the attacks. For a Senate seat with heavy national security jurisdiction, those statements give the Rogers campaign a ready and well-sourced attack line.
El-Sayed's high-profile advocacy for a Gaza ceasefire and alignment with the 2024 "uncommitted"…
El-Sayed's high-profile advocacy for a Gaza ceasefire and alignment with the 2024 "uncommitted" protest movement places him well to the left of Michigan's median voter on the cycle's most-discussed foreign policy issue. Rogers, with his intelligence committee background, is credibly positioned to frame the contrast as judgment vs. activism.
Senate influence depends heavily on seniority and committee assignments.
Senate influence depends heavily on seniority and committee assignments. Rogers, as a former committee chairman with deep Republican ties, would enter the Senate with far more leverage from day one than a freshman Democrat starting at the bottom of the queue.
El-Sayed's ties to organizations including the Islamic Society of North America (ISNA)
El-Sayed's ties to organizations including the Islamic Society of North America (ISNA) — which has faced federal scrutiny over funding connections — will be central to Republican opposition research. In a post-October 7 environment, the Rogers campaign will not leave the issue unaddressed.