The Times Topics How it works For Government
The Debate

SB 244 · Passed Senate · Now in House

Sen. Mark Huizenga has introduced SB 244 to raise the senior homestead property tax credit from $1,600 to $2,500 per year. Fixed-income seniors are being priced out of their homes as property values rise.

Where do you stand?
Source Library Source Documents (1)
Arguments

What people are saying for and against

Yes - support 4
24

Widowed, on Social Security and a small pension. My property taxes went up $340 this year because of my township's new millage.

I'm 74, widowed, on Social Security and a small pension. My property taxes went up $340 this year because of my township's new millage. My income did not go up $340. The homestead credit phases out above $63,000 in household income — that threshold hasn't been adjusted for inflation since 2012. In real terms, the credit covers a smaller share of the tax burden every year for people exactly like me. This isn't a hypothetical policy debate. It's happening to real people right now.

read more ↓
19

Kevin raises the fiscal point but misses the distributional one.

Kevin raises the fiscal point but misses the distributional one. Michigan's property tax burden as a share of income is highest for low-income seniors — exactly the population this credit targets. The alternative is seniors selling homes they've owned for 40 years because the tax bill exceeds their monthly income. That outcome has its own costs: displaced seniors, disrupted neighborhoods, increased demand for rental assistance and Medicaid-funded long-term care. The credit is cheaper than the alternative.

read more ↓
17

My husband and I have lived in our Ada Township home since 1981. We raised four kids here. The assessed value has tripled since we retired.

My husband and I have lived in our Ada Township home since 1981. We raised four kids here. The assessed value has tripled since we retired. Proposal A caps assessment increases at 5% or CPI, whichever is lower — that helps. But when you sell and rebuy, or when millages pass, or when your township reassesses commercial property and the residential share increases, the cap doesn't protect you. We're not rich because our house is worth more than we paid for it. We're just old.

read more ↓
15

Chris's point about means testing is worth taking seriously but the income threshold already does some of that work.

Chris's point about means testing is worth taking seriously but the income threshold already does some of that work. The credit phases out above $63K — the lakefront property owner isn't capturing most of it if they have retirement income above that threshold. The real design gap is the inflation adjustment. If the Legislature updated the $63K threshold for inflation annually, the credit would work as intended without the fiscal expansion of changing the credit amount itself.

read more ↓
No - oppose 2
11

The Senior Property Tax Credit currently costs the state roughly $440M annually.

The Senior Property Tax Credit currently costs the state roughly $440M annually. The proposed expansion would add an estimated $180-220M depending on the income threshold. That money has to come from somewhere — either cuts to other programs or revenue increases. I'm not opposed to helping seniors with fixed incomes. I'm opposed to a fiscal expansion without an honest accounting of what gets cut or who else pays.

read more ↓
8

Property tax relief for seniors is a reasonable goal. The right mechanism is means-tested and…

Property tax relief for seniors is a reasonable goal. The right mechanism is means-tested and time-limited — tied to demonstrated financial hardship, not just age. A blanket increase in the senior credit benefits an 80-year-old with a $1.2M lakefront property the same as one with a $140K bungalow. Design matters. The current proposal doesn't distinguish between those cases.

read more ↓
No arguments on this side yet.