The Times Topics How it works For Government
The Debate

Should Michigan state government accelerate EV adoption incentives even if it risks near-term auto jobs?

Michigan is the center of the U.S. auto industry's shift to electric vehicles. GM, Ford, and Stellantis have committed $30B+ in Michigan EV investments — but federal EV tax credit changes, Trump tariffs on Canadian auto parts, and battery factory labor disputes are reshaping the timeline and who benefits.

For

Yes — the global transition is happening; Michigan must lead it or lose to other states and countries

Against

No — the transition timeline should be driven by the market, not state mandates that risk UAW jobs

Where do you stand?
Arguments

What people are saying for and against

Yes — the global transition is happening; Michigan must lead it or lose to other states and countries 3
36

GM and Ford have already committed $50B combined to EV platforms. The question is not whether the transition is happening — it is.

GM and Ford have already committed $50B combined to EV platforms. The question is not whether the transition is happening — it is. The question is whether Michigan captures the battery, software, and manufacturing jobs or whether those go to Georgia, Tennessee, and South Korea. Michigan has the skilled trades, the supplier network, and the engineering talent. The state's job is to make Michigan the most competitive place to build the next generation of vehicles, not to protect the last generation.

read more ↓
23

The Ultium battery plant in Lansing and the SK On plant in Commerce Township together represent…

The Ultium battery plant in Lansing and the SK On plant in Commerce Township together represent 4,000 permanent manufacturing jobs and $7B in capital investment. Those plants exist because Michigan competed aggressively for them with state incentives. Without incentives, those jobs went to Ohio and Georgia. "Let the market decide" in practice means "let states with more aggressive incentive programs decide." That is not a neutral policy position.

read more ↓
15

China builds 60% of the world's EVs and controls 80% of the global battery supply chain.

China builds 60% of the world's EVs and controls 80% of the global battery supply chain. The CHIPS Act and IRA were specifically designed to rebuild US manufacturing capacity in critical technology sectors. Michigan's EV incentives are not independent state industrial policy — they are the implementation layer for federal strategy. Opting out of that strategy doesn't protect Michigan workers; it cedes the field to competitors who are not opting out.

read more ↓
No — the transition timeline should be driven by the market, not state mandates that risk UAW jobs 3
31

GM's Orion Assembly plant was retooled for EVs and then idled for two years because demand didn't meet projections.

GM's Orion Assembly plant was retooled for EVs and then idled for two years because demand didn't meet projections. Ford lost $4.7B on its EV division in 2023. The market is telling us something: EV adoption is slower than the policy assumptions behind state incentive programs. UAW members who retrained for EV platform jobs are sitting at home. I support the long-term transition. I don't support forcing the timeline faster than the market can absorb at the cost of Michigan workers' livelihoods right now.

read more ↓
19

ICE vehicle service jobs — mechanics, technicians, parts specialists

ICE vehicle service jobs — mechanics, technicians, parts specialists — outnumber EV manufacturing jobs in Michigan 4 to 1. EVs have 40% fewer parts than ICE vehicles and require dramatically less routine maintenance. Every EV sold reduces service revenue at independent repair shops and dealership service departments. The state EV incentive programs subsidize a technology transition that destroys more Michigan jobs in the service sector than it creates in manufacturing.

read more ↓
11

The state's 2035 EV sales mandate, adopted by administrative rule rather than legislation, requires…

The state's 2035 EV sales mandate, adopted by administrative rule rather than legislation, requires that 100% of new vehicle sales in Michigan be electric by 2035. That is nine years away. The charging infrastructure in the Upper Peninsula and rural Lower Michigan is completely inadequate to support that mandate. We are mandating a transition for which we have not built the basic infrastructure. This is not anti-EV — it is anti-policy-without-planning.

read more ↓
No arguments on this side yet.