Should Hillary Scholten be re-elected to represent Michigan's 3rd Congressional District in 2026?
Hillary Scholten (D) represents Michigan's 3rd Congressional District — covering Kent County (Grand Rapids, Cascade, Ada) and parts of Ionia and Montcalm counties. She narrowly held the seat in 2024 in a district Trump carried. The 2026 race is among the most competitive House seats in Michigan.
Yes — Scholten has been effective on West Michigan priorities and should continue
No — the district needs new leadership that better reflects its values
What people are saying for and against
Scholten secured $47M in Bipartisan Infrastructure Law funding for West Michigan projects: the…
Scholten secured $47M in Bipartisan Infrastructure Law funding for West Michigan projects: the Beltline Ave interchange, the GR water system upgrade, and the rural broadband co-op expansion in Ionia County. She did that in her first two years as a freshman in the minority. For a district that last had a Republican incumbent for 16 years, that's a real return on a competitive race. Don't trade that seniority for a freshman Republican.
The alternative to Scholten is a Republican in a district that was deliberately gerrymandered to be competitive.
The alternative to Scholten is a Republican in a district that was deliberately gerrymandered to be competitive. That means a Republican who wins MI-03 is a Republican who can also lose it — i.e., someone who will vote with the national party 90% of the time to avoid a primary challenge. Scholten has actually broken from the national party on agricultural trade issues that affect West Michigan directly. A competitive-district Republican won't do that.
The redistricting that created the current MI-03 was done by an independent commission. That's a real democratic win that Scholten supported.
The redistricting that created the current MI-03 was done by an independent commission. That's a real democratic win that Scholten supported. Whoever holds this seat in 2027 will serve through the next redistricting cycle. Having a member who supported independent redistricting actually in the room when those maps are drawn is worth a lot more than one policy disagreement.
Scholten voted for the Inflation Reduction Act, the student loan forgiveness executive action support, and the COVID spending packages.
Scholten voted for the Inflation Reduction Act, the student loan forgiveness executive action support, and the COVID spending packages. Every one of those votes added to the federal deficit and contributed to the inflation that hit Kent County manufacturing workers and retirees hardest. She represents a district that went 50-50 in 2022 — she has not governed toward the center of her constituency.
Kent County's agricultural economy depends on H-2A visa workers.
Kent County's agricultural economy depends on H-2A visa workers. Scholten voted against the Farm Workforce Modernization Act in 2021 on grounds that it didn't include enough labor protections — a vote that killed the best chance at a bipartisan agricultural guest worker fix in fifteen years. Farmers in my area needed that bill. Her "no" vote was driven by urban labor coalition politics, not by what her rural constituents needed.