Should Grand Rapids prioritize enforcement of anti-camping rules over expanded shelter funding?
Grand Rapids has one of the highest rates of visible homelessness among mid-sized U.S. cities. The city commission is debating whether to prioritize enforcement of anti-camping ordinances or expand shelter capacity and wraparound services — and who pays for it.
Yes — clear public spaces, enforce existing law
No — expand shelter and services first
What people are saying for and against
The encampments between Fuller and Hall have been there for eighteen months. Three of my employees have been harassed on their way to work.
I own a business on South Division. The encampments between Fuller and Hall have been there for eighteen months. Three of my employees have been harassed on their way to work. A customer's car was broken into in my parking lot twice. The city has a camping ordinance and a public urination ordinance and neither is being enforced. I'm not asking for anyone to be put in jail. I'm asking the law to be applied equally regardless of housing status.
The Downtown Market area sees heavy foot traffic from families with kids.
The Downtown Market area sees heavy foot traffic from families with kids. The intersection of Oakes and Ionia has been the site of multiple public drug use incidents in the past six months. I fully support expanded shelter funding — I voted for the millage. But "services first" cannot be a rationale for indefinitely tolerating conditions that make public space unsafe for everyone else. Both things have to happen simultaneously, not sequentially.
The city has Assertive Community Treatment teams. The Lighthouse has a rapid rehousing program. The Mel Trotter shelter has intake capacity.
The city has Assertive Community Treatment teams. The Lighthouse has a rapid rehousing program. The Mel Trotter shelter has intake capacity. The GRPD's homeless liaison officer program has been running for three years. The services exist. The problem is that accepting services is voluntary and a significant percentage of the unsheltered population in GR has active substance use disorders or severe mental illness that prevents them from voluntarily engaging. At some point, involuntary intervention has to be part of the toolkit.
Heartside Ministry serves 200 people per day. The shelter system in Grand Rapids has 487 beds.
Heartside Ministry serves 200 people per day. The shelter system in Grand Rapids has 487 beds. On any given night there are 800-1,200 people experiencing homelessness in the city. You cannot enforce your way out of a situation where you don't have enough shelter beds. Every encampment cleared without a shelter placement just moves the problem three blocks. The Supreme Court's Grants Pass decision allows enforcement, but enforcement without beds is just organized cruelty.
Housing First is the evidence-based intervention. The Salt Lake City model reduced chronic…
Housing First is the evidence-based intervention. The Salt Lake City model reduced chronic homelessness by 91% in eight years using Housing First, not enforcement. Grand Rapids spent $4.2M on encampment clearances in 2024-2025. That money, redirected to rapid rehousing vouchers, would have housed approximately 140 people permanently. We are spending money to move people around instead of spending it to actually house them.
West Michigan has one of the highest church-to-population ratios in the country.
West Michigan has one of the highest church-to-population ratios in the country. Every faith community in this region has some capacity for service partnership. The question is whether the city's approach builds that coalition or burns it. Enforcement-first approaches historically drive unsheltered people out of the city center into suburban and rural areas where services are even thinner. We export the problem; we don't solve it.