The Times Topics How it works For Government
The Debate

Should Grand Rapids require developers to include affordable units in new market-rate projects?

Grand Rapids needs an estimated 8,500 additional affordable housing units for low- and moderate-income households. The city commission is debating inclusionary zoning requirements, ADU policy, and whether to pre-empt state legislation that would limit local housing control.

For

Yes — inclusionary zoning is necessary to maintain mixed-income neighborhoods

Against

No — mandates reduce overall housing production and push costs onto market-rate buyers

Where do you stand?
Arguments

What people are saying for and against

Yes — inclusionary zoning is necessary to maintain mixed-income neighborhoods 3
35

I cannot afford to rent within 20 minutes of work. My two options are a 45-minute commute from…

I am a nurse at Spectrum. I cannot afford to rent within 20 minutes of work. My two options are a 45-minute commute from Kentwood or a 55% rent-to-income ratio in a studio near the hospital. The market is not solving this and has not solved it for five years. The argument that inclusionary zoning will reduce total housing supply is a theoretical concern. The reality I am living is a concrete fact.

read more ↓
22

The mixed-income neighborhood argument is not just about individual units

The mixed-income neighborhood argument is not just about individual units — it's about school quality, neighborhood investment, and intergenerational mobility. Studies from the Urban Institute show that children who grow up in mixed-income neighborhoods have meaningfully better adult income outcomes. Allowing all new construction to be market-rate concentrates affordable units in low-investment areas and perpetuates segregation. The 15% set-aside requirement in the proposed ordinance is the minimum to maintain economic diversity.

read more ↓
14

Grand Rapids has $42M in ARPA housing funds that can be structured as gap financing specifically to make inclusionary projects pencil.

Grand Rapids has $42M in ARPA housing funds that can be structured as gap financing specifically to make inclusionary projects pencil. The feasibility study that opponents cite assumes no gap financing. With the city acting as gap lender at below-market rates, the inclusionary math changes significantly. The question is whether the commission is willing to deploy the ARPA housing allocation proactively, not whether inclusionary zoning is theoretically impossible.

read more ↓
No — mandates reduce overall housing production and push costs onto market-rate buyers 2
29

Minneapolis eliminated single-family zoning and removed most density restrictions in 2019 without inclusionary mandates.

Minneapolis eliminated single-family zoning and removed most density restrictions in 2019 without inclusionary mandates. By 2023, rent in Minneapolis had declined 4% while rents in comparable Minnesota cities rose 14%. The Minneapolis model suggests that removing supply barriers — not mandating affordable set-asides — is what actually makes housing cheaper. Inclusionary zoning in San Francisco produced 23,000 affordable units in 30 years and rent went up 180% anyway.

read more ↓
18

The city's own housing feasibility study, done by Development Strategies Inc., found that mandatory…

The city's own housing feasibility study, done by Development Strategies Inc., found that mandatory inclusionary zoning at 15% would make approximately 60% of currently penciling market-rate projects non-viable. That's not a developer complaint — it's a financial model. Construction costs in Grand Rapids are $285-310/SF for mid-rise. When you require 15% of units to sell or rent at 60% AMI, the remaining 85% have to subsidize that loss. At current land costs, it doesn't work.

read more ↓
No arguments on this side yet.