The Times Topics How it works For Government
The Debate

Should Forest Hills Public Schools prioritize protecting classroom teachers and core academics over extracurricular programs in the $4.2 million budget reduction?

FHPS is closing a $4.2 million budget gap driven by declining enrollment (which cuts per-pupil state funding) and rising MPSERS retirement costs. Proposed cuts: extracurricular bus service reduced 40%, 6 instructional coach positions eliminated, summer enrichment program cut. The Board of Education votes on the final budget by June 30, 2026. Parents can comment at board meetings before the vote.

For

Yes — protect classrooms first, cut non-core programs

Against

No — extracurriculars and support staff matter equally

Where do you stand?
Arguments

What people are saying for and against

Yes — protect classrooms first, cut non-core programs 3
26

My daughter is in a fifth-grade class of 31 students. FHPS class sizes have grown four students per…

My daughter is in a fifth-grade class of 31 students. FHPS class sizes have grown four students per class over the past five years as the district managed budget pressure by not replacing teachers who retired. That's the real cut that happened quietly. I'd rather see the debate club and the JV golf team take cuts before we add a 32nd student to an already-crowded elementary classroom.

read more ↓
17

The state foundation allowance hasn't kept pace with inflation in seven of the last ten years.

The state foundation allowance hasn't kept pace with inflation in seven of the last ten years. FHPS is dealing with a structural revenue problem, not just a one-time shortfall. In that environment, the only sustainable long-term choice is to concentrate resources on the core instructional program — teacher-to-student ratio, curriculum materials, professional development — and accept that everything else is supplemental. Hard, but that's the math.

read more ↓
11

The FHPS budget includes an activities fee that can be waived for low-income students but in practice very few families apply for the waiver.

The FHPS budget includes an activities fee that can be waived for low-income students but in practice very few families apply for the waiver. A lot of the programs we're debating cutting already have informal access barriers. If we're honest, "protecting extracurriculars" often means protecting programs that predominantly serve kids whose families can afford the equipment, travel, and time costs anyway.

read more ↓
No — extracurriculars and support staff matter equally 2
22

The framing of "classrooms vs. everything else" is a false choice that gets used every budget cycle…

I'm a varsity coach and a classroom teacher. The framing of "classrooms vs. everything else" is a false choice that gets used every budget cycle to cut extracurriculars, which then makes the next budget cut easier to justify. The research on extracurricular participation and graduation rates, college attendance, and lifetime earnings is clear. Cutting JV sports and music programs to preserve one additional minute of instructional time is not an obvious trade.

read more ↓
14

My son has ADHD and would not still be in school without the support staff

My son has ADHD and would not still be in school without the support staff — the social worker, the resource room teacher, the school psychologist. These positions are always framed as "non-classroom" in budget discussions but they are what keep kids in the classroom. Before we cut anything, the district should publish a full accounting of what "support staff" actually does, not a line-item budget that obscures the function.

read more ↓
No arguments on this side yet.