Debate Explorer

What is the best reaction to an alien encounter ?

Technology
Aliens, Behavior, Encounter, Life, Universe

Our universe is so immense, that it is very tempting to imagine that Earth may not be the only planet hosting life. The idea of some alien life visiting Earth has been developed countless times in science-fiction books, movies, and other media.

What if they really existed, and came to visit us ? What if for some reason the first person they encountered was a simple citizen (not a State president, not a UN member, nor anyone with a special position to handle this situation) ? That citizen could be you. What should you do ?

Should you interact with the alien or wait until he does the first move ? Should you run away or fight him ? Should you call some State agent to inform the situation, or try to keep it secret ? Should you even believe it's real, or assume it's a dream or a fake ?

There are many UFO or alien testimonials, yet none of them has been generally and scientifically confirmed. We will then assume that such alien encounter is unprecedented, and that we can only try to guess which action would be most likely to have a positive outcome.

Each thesis developed here will be one possible action. Each must be independent from the others, yet they do not necessarily exclude each other as many actions could be done successively.

As an alien encounter can take various forms, it is recommended to clearly state which hypothesis you assume in your claim (when relevant). For example "If the alien is humanoid, then..."., or "If the alien seem dangerous, then..."

Economic Growth

Pro

AI technologies will dramatically increase productivity across sectors, creating new economic value and opportunities that outweigh job displacement.

Key Evidence

PwC research estimates AI could add $15.7 trillion to global GDP by 2030

42 contributors

Existential Risk

Con

Advanced AI systems could potentially pose existential risks to humanity if they develop goals misaligned with human values or escape human control.

Key Evidence

Open letter signed by 1,000+ AI researchers calling for pause on advanced AI development

36 contributors

Bias & Fairness

Neutral

AI systems can reflect and amplify existing societal biases, leading to unfair outcomes in areas like hiring, lending, criminal justice, and healthcare.

Key Evidence

Multiple studies show facial recognition systems have higher error rates for women and people with darker skin tones

51 contributors

News

EU Passes Comprehensive AI Act

The European Union has approved landmark legislation to regulate artificial intelligence, establishing the world's first comprehensive legal framework for AI.

June 10, 2025 • Read more

UN Establishes Global AI Ethics Committee

The United Nations has formed a specialized committee to develop international standards for ethical AI development and deployment.

May 28, 2025 • Read more

Major Tech Companies Sign AI Safety Pledge

Leading technology firms have jointly committed to a set of principles for responsible AI development, including safety testing and transparency measures.

May 15, 2025 • Read more

Worldview

2.4M Supporters
196 Countries

Support Distribution

42%
North America
28%
Europe
18%
Asia Pacific
12%
Other Regions
View Full Map
Weekly Growth
+12.4%
Active Debates
1,284
Top Supporters
JD
Dr. James Davis
AI Researcher • Stanford
MK
Dr. Michael Kim
Ethics Professor • MIT
EL
Emma Liu
Economist • World Bank
Public Opinion
Show %
Key Concerns